Estate Planning

Canadians with assets abroad: one will, two or three?

TheWILL.ai Team

For Canadians who own a home, an account or a pension in another country, whether one will is enough depends on provincial law, the law where the asset sits, and how the documents are drafted to fit together.

Canadians with assets abroad: one will, two or three?
This article coversCanadaCanada

There is no Canadian law of wills. Succession is a provincial matter, so a person living in Canada makes a will under the law of Ontario, British Columbia, Alberta, Quebec or another province or territory, and each has its own statute. Add a flat overseas, a pension from a former job abroad or a condo in the sun, and a second set of rules arrives alongside the first.

This article gives general information about how wills and foreign assets interact under Canadian provincial law. It is not legal or tax advice, and it does not tell anyone how to arrange their own affairs. Laws change, and how they apply turns on the facts.

Ten provinces, three territories, one country

For a Canadian, "one will or two?" starts with a prior question: which province's law is doing the talking. The common law provinces share broadly similar rules. Quebec is different in kind. It is a civil law jurisdiction, and article 712 of the Civil Code of Québec recognises only three forms of will: the notarial will, the holograph will and the will made in the presence of witnesses.

Where property sits outside Canada, two statutory questions matter most: what cancels an earlier will, and which country's law governs a gift of foreign property. Ontario's and British Columbia's statutes are drawn on below.

What cancels a will already signed

Section 15 of Ontario's Succession Law Reform Act lists the only ways a will can be revoked. One of them is another will made in accordance with that Part of the Act. Another is a signed writing declaring an intention to revoke. (Marriage used to be on the list; that limb was repealed with effect from 1 January 2022.) British Columbia's section 55 of the Wills, Estates and Succession Act works in a similar way: a will is revoked by a later will, by a written declaration, or by destruction with the intention of revoking, and the section says expressly that a change in circumstances is not enough on its own.

The practical consequence for anyone with a will in two countries is plain. A standard clause saying "I revoke all former wills" means precisely that. The statute draws no line between an earlier will made in Canada and one made in Lisbon, or one that dealt only with property abroad. A Canadian will signed later, with that clause, can cancel a foreign will the person meant to keep. The same is true the other way round: a new will made abroad, drafted by someone who has never seen the Canadian one, can wipe it out.

Where there is no revocation clause, conflict does the damage instead: a later will that deals with the same property differently can override the earlier one where the two clash, leaving executors to work out which document governs which asset, sometimes in two languages.

Foreign land and the law of its location

Section 36(1) of the Succession Law Reform Act says that the formalities, essential validity and effect of a will, so far as it relates to an interest in land, are governed by the internal law of the place where the land is situated. Section 36(2) sends movables, such as bank balances and shares, to the law of the place where the person was domiciled at death.

So an Ontario court looking at a will that leaves a house in Portugal will ask what Portuguese law says about that house. If the other country has forced heirship rules, which reserve a share of the estate for children or a spouse regardless of the will, those rules may govern the land whatever the Canadian will says. Portugal, like most EU member states, also applies the EU Succession Regulation (Regulation 650/2012), which has its own rules on which country's law governs a whole estate.

On form, the law is more forgiving. Section 37(1) of the Ontario Act treats a will as formally valid if, when it was made, it complied with the internal law of the place where it was made, where the person was domiciled, where they had their habitual residence, or of which they were a national. British Columbia's section 80 takes a similar, generous approach, and its section 82 accepts a will disposing of foreign land if it is made in the form that the law of the place where the land lies requires.

Formal validity is not the same as transfer. Land abroad generally has to pass through a local process in the country where it sits: an ancillary probate, a resealing of the Canadian grant, or a notarial procedure. A Canadian grant of probate is rarely enough on its own to change the name on a foreign title.

More than one will is a recognised arrangement

Ontario practitioners have long drafted two wills for one person: a primary will for assets that need a grant of probate, and a secondary will for assets that do not, such as shares in a private company. The court in Granovsky Estate v. Ontario (1998), 156 D.L.R. (4th) 557, accepted that a person can leave more than one valid will, each dealing with different property. The same drafting idea extends naturally to property abroad: one will for Canadian assets, and one made under local law for property in another country.

The arrangement depends on drafting. Each will limits itself to the property it covers, and each revocation clause is confined to earlier wills dealing with that same property.

A multi-will arrangement is only as good as the executors' ability to find every document. Many people keep a note of where each will is held, and a will registry helps make sure a will is found when it matters.

How the answer shifts from family to family

An Alberta pharmacist with a flat in Manila. She inherited her late father's apartment and has a Canadian will leaving everything to her two children. Transferring a Philippine title generally involves a Philippine court process, and foreign ownership of land and condominium units in the Philippines carries its own restrictions. Some people in her position hold a local will for the apartment; others rely on having the Canadian will recognised there. Either way, the two documents have to agree on who gets what.

A Montreal restaurateur with a family house in Portugal. He made a notarial will in Quebec years ago, and has since thought about a Portuguese will for the house his grandparents built. Quebec's Civil Code, like Ontario's statute, treats succession to immovables abroad as a matter for the law of the place they sit. Portuguese succession law includes reserved shares for close family, so a gift of the whole house to one person may not survive as written. If he signs a Portuguese will, whether its revocation wording reaches back to his Quebec will is the question that most needs checking.

A Vancouver architect with a pension in Ireland. She spent her late twenties in Dublin and left an occupational pension there. Benefits of that kind often sit outside a will altogether, because the scheme's trustees usually choose who receives them, taking the member's stated wishes into account. For her, a second will may not be the point. Keeping the nomination current, and keeping a record of the scheme and its contact details alongside her other assets, may matter more. An asset tracker records assets in one portfolio, which is often where a forgotten pension turns up.

The three cases get three different answers, because the number of wills follows the asset and its country rather than any general rule.

How the documents sit together

Take a retired couple in Ontario who spend their winters in a Florida condo. Each has an Ontario will covering their home, their savings and their registered accounts. The condo is Florida land, so under section 36(1) of the Succession Law Reform Act, an Ontario court will look to Florida law for it, and in practice the condo will commonly pass through a Florida ancillary probate.

Some couples in that position keep their Ontario wills for everything in Canada and sign Florida wills limited to the condo. Each will then confines its revocation clause to property it covers, so a future update to the Ontario will does not cancel the Florida one, and the reverse. Each set of executors knows the other set exists and where to find the other will. A platform that coordinates wills across jurisdictions from one platform is one way to keep both documents in view, and the Canada legal guide sets out the provincial background. Other couples choose a single Ontario will and accept a Florida ancillary process when the time comes. Either path involves the same underlying task: making sure the documents, wherever they sit, agree with one another.

Whether one will or several suits a particular estate turns on the province, the countries where the property sits, the kind of assets involved and the family's circumstances, and it is a question for a qualified professional in each of those places.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.