One will or two? Holding assets in India and abroad
For people living in India with a flat, shares or a bank account abroad, an Indian will is only part of the picture. How Indian law treats foreign assets, and why one standard clause can cancel another will.
Section 5 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 splits a single estate in two. Succession to immovable property in India follows Indian law wherever the owner was domiciled; succession to movable property follows the law of the country where the owner was domiciled at death. For a family in Bengaluru who bought a flat in Dubai a few years ago, that split is not an abstract point of private international law. It is the reason their Indian will may say one thing about the flat while the rules in Dubai decide something else.
What follows is general information about how the law works, written for readers living in India. It is not legal or tax advice, and it does not say what any particular family ought to do.
Two countries, two sets of rules for the same estate
The Bengaluru couple are an architect and a school principal with two children at secondary school. Their home, savings and provident fund are all in India. The Dubai flat was bought as an investment and is let out. Each has an Indian will leaving everything to the other and then to the children.
Under Indian law, their bank accounts and shares would ordinarily pass under the law of their domicile, which is India. The flat is different. Immovable property is generally governed by the law of the place where it sits, known as the lex situs, and Indian courts generally apply that principle to land abroad. So the question of who inherits the Dubai flat, and on what terms, is answered first by the rules of the UAE and not by the couple's Indian will alone.
The same holds for a house in a US state or a flat in London. Money and shares are more flexible in principle, but a foreign bank or broker will usually release them only against paperwork its own courts recognise.
Which Indian law applies depends on who is making the will
Indian succession law is not one system. Section 4 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 provides that the Part of the Act containing section 5 does not apply where the deceased was a Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist, Sikh or Jain. For those families, the domicile and situs split comes through general conflict-of-laws principles developed by the courts, which reach a broadly similar result, rather than through the statute itself.
The rules on making a will also vary:
- Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs and Jains. Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956 allows a Hindu to dispose of property by will in accordance with the Indian Succession Act. Through section 57 and Schedule III of the 1925 Act, the formal requirements in section 63 apply to these wills.
- Muslims. Wills are governed by Muslim personal law rather than by the execution rules of the 1925 Act. Under that personal law, a bequest is generally limited to one third of the estate remaining after funeral expenses and debts, and a bequest to an heir, or of more than one third, generally needs the consent of the other heirs.
- Everyone else, including Christians and Parsis, is covered by the 1925 Act directly, with Parsi intestacy under its own chapter.
Section 63 sets out the familiar formalities for an unprivileged will: the testator signs or puts a mark on it, and at least two witnesses attest it, each having seen the testator sign or received the testator's acknowledgement of the signature. Whether a foreign court accepts the result is a question for that court's own rules. The India legal guide covers the domestic side of Indian wills in more detail.
What an Indian will can say about a flat overseas
An Indian will can mention foreign property, and there is nothing unusual in a clause leaving "my flat in Dubai" to a named person. What the Indian will cannot do is override the law of the place where the flat sits.
In the UAE, for example, succession to property of non-Muslim residents and owners has been addressed in recent federal legislation on civil personal status, and registration services for non-Muslim wills exist through bodies such as the DIFC Courts' Wills Service Centre and the Abu Dhabi Judicial Department. A family relying only on an Indian will may be asked for a locally recognised document before anything changes hands, and many owners hold a separate UAE-registered will limited to their UAE assets.
A retired textile trader in Pune shows the movable side of the same problem. He bought US shares through a brokerage account under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme, the Reserve Bank of India framework letting resident individuals send money abroad up to an annual limit, and his son now lives in the US. The shares are movable and would follow the law of his Indian domicile. But the broker will look to US law, and often to a court in a particular state, before transferring them. The Indian will can be right in principle and still not be enough in practice.
When a foreign court is asked to act on an Indian will
An executor usually needs a grant from a court where the asset is. There are broadly three routes, and which are open depends on the foreign country's rules:
- Resealing, where a foreign court stamps an existing grant from another country so it has effect locally. Some Commonwealth jurisdictions allow this for grants from listed countries.
- An ancillary grant, where the foreign court issues its own grant based on the Indian will or the Indian grant.
- A fresh application, where the will is proved again from the beginning under local procedure.
Indian law has a matching route for wills proved elsewhere. Section 228 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 allows letters of administration to be granted in India with a copy of the will annexed, where the will has already been proved and deposited in a competent court outside India and a properly authenticated copy is produced.
A Delhi business owner who runs a distribution firm bought a flat in London as a base for his trips to trade fairs. His Indian will covers it. To sell or transfer that flat after his death, his executor would normally need an English grant. English law generally accepts a will as formally valid if it was properly made where it was signed, but the grant, forms and timetable all follow English procedure.
A widowed mother in Kolkata faces the same issue on a smaller scale. She worked in Singapore for several years in hotel accounts and still has a savings account there. Her children expect it to be simple, but the Singapore bank will usually want a grant recognised in Singapore before releasing the balance, and Kolkata itself sits within one of the areas where section 213 of the 1925 Act can require probate before an executor's rights are established in an Indian court.
The clause that can undo the other will
A second will abroad brings its own hazard. Many wills begin with a standard revocation clause, something like "I revoke all former wills and codicils". Section 70 of the Indian Succession Act 1925 provides that an unprivileged will can be revoked by another will or codicil. Nothing in that section limits the effect to wills made in India.
So if the Bengaluru couple sign a UAE will with a general revocation clause, it may cancel their Indian wills. If they later update their Indian wills with the same wording, the Indian wills may cancel the UAE ones. Inconsistency can do the same work with no clause at all: a later will leaving "all my property" to someone can displace an earlier will's gifts so far as the two cannot both be carried out.
Families who hold two wills commonly handle this in a few consistent ways. Each will is limited to the assets in its own country. Each revocation clause revokes only earlier wills dealing with the same assets, and says so. Each will refers to the existence of the other, so an executor in either country is not surprised. A change to one prompts a reread of the other. Coordinating wills across jurisdictions from one platform is what multi-jurisdiction is built for, and the global assets page covers how residents of India with assets in several countries tend to think about the whole picture.
A will nobody knows about
The last hazard is the simplest. A second will filed away in the UAE, or held by a lawyer in London, is only useful if the executors in India know it exists. Executors abroad need to know about the Indian will just as much. The will registry helps make sure a will is found when it matters, as does a short note in the family papers of which will covers which country.
Back to the flat overseas
The Bengaluru couple's wills were drafted for a life lived in India, and mostly it still is. The flat is the one asset the Indian wills describe but do not control. Whether they keep one will each or add a second in the UAE, what matters is that the documents know about each other, that neither quietly revokes the other, and that their children can find both.
Religion, domicile, the type of asset and the country where it sits all change the answer, so the position of any one family is something for a qualified professional in India, and one in each other country involved, to look at.
Sources
- Indian Succession Act, 1925 (opens in a new tab), sections 4 and 5, India Code, Part II excludes Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist, Sikh and Jain deceased; otherwise immovables in India follow Indian law and movables the law of domicile
- Indian Succession Act, 1925 (opens in a new tab), sections 57, 63 and Schedule III, India Code, execution of unprivileged wills and its application to wills of Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs and Jains
- Indian Succession Act, 1925 (opens in a new tab), section 70, India Code, revocation of an unprivileged will by another will or codicil, a written declaration or destruction
- Indian Succession Act, 1925 (opens in a new tab), section 213, India Code, when probate or letters of administration are needed to establish an executor's or legatee's right in court
- Indian Succession Act, 1925 (opens in a new tab), section 228, India Code, letters of administration with copy annexed of a will proved and deposited abroad
- Hindu Succession Act, 1956, section 30, India Code, testamentary disposition by Hindus in accordance with the Indian Succession Act
- Liberalised Remittance Scheme, Reserve Bank of India, framework for resident individuals remitting funds abroad within an annual limit
Written by
TheWILL.ai Team
The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.


