Estate Planning

Northern Ireland wills and assets abroad: where two wills collide

TheWILL.ai Team

A Northern Ireland grant reaches England, Wales and Scotland, but not a cottage over the border. How Northern Ireland law treats a second will made for property abroad.

Northern Ireland wills and assets abroad: where two wills collide
This article coversUnited Kingdom - Northern IrelandUnited Kingdom - Northern Ireland

A grant of probate issued in Belfast is recognised in England, Wales and Scotland without any further step. Drive twenty minutes from Newry into the Republic and it stops counting, which is why so many people here end up asking whether one will is enough.

A general guide only: this describes how Northern Ireland law deals with wills and property elsewhere, and it is neither legal nor tax advice for any particular estate.

A grant that stops at the border

Section 1(4) of the Administration of Estates Act 1971 provides that a grant made by the High Court in Northern Ireland, for someone who died domiciled here, is treated in England and Wales as if it had been made there, without being resealed. Section 3 of the same Act gives Northern Ireland grants parallel recognition in Scotland. Probate applications in Northern Ireland are handled by the Probate Office at the Royal Courts of Justice in Belfast.

The Republic of Ireland is a separate state with its own succession law and its own courts. Property there generally needs an Irish grant, applied for in Ireland, and Irish law has its own rules, including a fixed share for a surviving spouse or civil partner that a will does not simply override.

Take a couple in Newry with a holiday cottage in Donegal. Their house and savings sit under Northern Ireland law; the cottage sits under Irish law and needs an Irish grant. Some families in that position keep one will; others add a second, made in the Republic, for the cottage alone. Trouble starts when the two are not drafted to fit together.

How one will can cancel another

Article 14 of the Wills and Administration Proceedings (Northern Ireland) Order 1994 sets out the only ways a will made here can be revoked: by marriage or civil partnership under the rules that follow in the Order, by another will, by a signed writing declaring an intention to revoke, or by burning, tearing or destroying it with that intention.

"By another will" is where cross-border arrangements go wrong. A standard revocation clause, the line that revokes all earlier wills, takes no notice of the border. If the couple's Donegal will is made second and opens with that clause, it can wipe out their Northern Ireland will, leaving their home here to pass under the intestacy rules. A later will that simply says something inconsistent with an earlier one can also displace the earlier gift, even without a revocation clause.

Article 12 adds a second trap. Marriage revokes a will made in Northern Ireland, unless the will shows it was made expecting marriage to a particular person and was meant to survive it. Someone who marries after making wills in two countries may find one revoked and the other still standing, because the other country's law may not treat marriage the same way.

Which country's formalities count

The Wills Act 1963 extends to Northern Ireland; section 7(5) declares it. Under section 1, a will is treated as properly executed if it followed the law of the place where it was signed, or of the testator's domicile, habitual residence or nationality, either when it was signed or at death. Section 2(1)(b) adds that, so far as a will deals with land, it is also formally valid if it followed the law of the place where the land sits.

That is generous about signing but says nothing about who inherits. Succession to land is generally governed by the law of the country where the land is. Our Northern Ireland wills guide covers the local signing rules, and our page on wills in more than one country covers arrangements for people with wills in several places.

Examples that pull in different directions

A retired postman from Lisburn owns an apartment on the Costa Blanca. Spain applies the EU Succession Regulation 650/2012, which generally looks to the law of the country where the person was habitually resident, unless the will chooses the law of their nationality. How that meets the Northern Ireland rule for land is technical, and the apartment is still handled through Spanish notaries. A Spanish will limited to the Spanish property is a common arrangement, provided its revocation wording leaves the Northern Ireland will untouched.

A young quantity surveyor came home from a working holiday in Australia with superannuation still in an Australian fund. Superannuation often does not pass under a will at all: the fund trustee pays it out, guided by any nomination the member has made. A will leaving "everything in Australia" to a sibling may have no effect on it.

A café owner in Enniskillen holds a joint account at a Canadian bank with her brother, who lives in Toronto. Joint accounts commonly pass to the surviving holder outside any will, though Canadian courts can look at whether that was really intended. Her Northern Ireland will may say one thing about the money while the account terms say another.

A will that cannot be found

None of this helps if the family does not know a second will exists. Northern Ireland has no compulsory central register of wills, and a will lodged with a notary in Alicante or a firm in Letterkenny can easily be missed by executors working in Belfast. A service such as the will registry helps make sure a will is found when it matters, and an asset tracker records assets in one portfolio, so the executors can see that there is a cottage, a fund or an account to look for.

Where an estate spans the border or reaches further afield, the right answer turns on which countries are involved, what kind of property is held there and the family's own situation, and each piece is worth checking with a qualified professional in the country concerned.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.