Estate Planning

A will can name a guardian in Canada, but which province decides how long it lasts

TheWILL.ai Team

There is no single Canadian rule on who raises a child when both parents die. British Columbia, Ontario and Quebec each answer it differently, from a guardian whose appointment can stand to one whose authority runs out after 90 days.

A will can name a guardian in Canada, but which province decides how long it lastsA will can name a guardian in Canada, but which province decides how long it lasts
This article coversCanadaCanada

In Ontario, a guardian named in a will has authority for only about 90 days before the court has to be asked to decide, and in Quebec the same job is split between a person who raises the child and a council that watches over the money. Neither of those facts is true everywhere in Canada, because child welfare and guardianship belong to the provinces and territories rather than to Ottawa.

This article is about Canada, where this is provincial and territorial law. The provisions discussed are British Columbia's, Ontario's and Quebec's; the other provinces and the territories run their own, and some use different words for the same idea. It is general information, not legal advice. Rules change, and a lawyer or notary can speak to an individual family's position.

Three provinces, three vocabularies

The word guardian does not travel well across the country. British Columbia uses guardianship and treats it as the ordinary legal status of a parent. Ontario's Children's Law Reform Act speaks of decision-making responsibility, a term that replaced older language about custody. Quebec, a civil-law jurisdiction, speaks of parental authority while the parents live and of tutorship when they cannot act, and the tutor is a separate role from the person who has day-to-day care of the child.

Behind the vocabulary the question is the same one: if no parent is left, who has the legal right to make decisions for a minor, and who chose that person? How each province answers it turns on three things in turn: whether a will can do the choosing, how long the choice lasts, and what a court does with it.

British Columbia: a will, or a form, can name a successor

The Family Law Act (SBC 2011, c 25) is the starting point. A child's guardians are usually decided by the family situation under the Act, and a parent who is a guardian can appoint someone to act after they die under section 53. That can be done in a will or another written instrument. Law firm commentary adds that the person named has to accept the appointment, and that a parent who is not already a guardian does not automatically become one when the other parent dies.

One detail matters for families where the parents are separated. If one parent dies and the other is also a guardian, the survivor generally continues as guardian. The appointment is mainly relevant where no surviving guardian remains.

If there is no appointment and no surviving guardian, section 51 of the Act allows the court to appoint a guardian. A named person does not close the door on the court either: the Act's overriding concern is the child's best interests, and an interested person can apply to the court about who should act.

Ontario: the appointment buys time

Section 61 of the Children's Law Reform Act lets a person with decision-making responsibility for a child appoint someone by will to have that responsibility after the appointor's death. Two practical features set Ontario apart.

The first is the survivor rule. Where a child has two parents who both hold decision-making responsibility and one dies, the other normally carries on. The will appointment is aimed at the case where the last parent dies, and a couple who each appoint someone may want to take advice on how the two appointments fit together.

The second is duration. Commentary on the Act describes a testamentary appointment as effective for a limited period, about 90 days, during which the appointed person can apply to the court. The court then decides who should have decision-making responsibility, and its test is the best interests of the child, not the wording of the will. Other relatives are free to put forward competing applications.

Authority over a child's assets is generally treated separately from decision-making about their care, and a court process may be involved. So an Ontario will that names a guardian for the child may not by itself hand over control of an inheritance, and a family may want to ask a lawyer about a trust for the child's money.

Quebec: the last parent chooses a tutor, and a council keeps watch

Quebec's Civil Code builds the system differently, and the Public Curator of Quebec publishes plain-language guidance on it. When both parents have died or cannot act, a dative tutor takes over. The right to name one belongs to the last surviving parent, and where several designations exist, the wishes of the last parent to die or become incapable are the ones that apply.

The appointment can be made in a will, which may be notarial, holographic or witnessed, in a protection mandate, or in a declaration of dative tutorship sent to the Public Curator. The declaration is the unusual feature: it is a separate route that does not depend on a will being found and verified.

Three further points are particular to Quebec:

  • Acceptance has a clock. A named tutor is presumed to have accepted unless they refuse within 30 days of learning of the appointment.
  • A tutorship council oversees the tutor. Where a tutor manages a child's property, the law generally requires a tutorship council, a small group that represents the child's interests and supervises how the tutor administers that property.
  • The roles can be split. The tutor to the person has to be an individual. A tutor to the property can also be a legal entity such as a financial institution.

If no tutor was named, the court can appoint one, including on the application of an interested person.

What the three have in common, and where the rest of Canada fits

Read together, the three provinces share a shape even though they differ in detail. A parent can usually name someone in advance, the named person can say no, and the court can be asked to look again with the child's interests in front of it. They differ on how much a will can do alone: British Columbia lets the appointment carry through, Ontario treats it as a bridge to a court order, and Quebec adds a council to oversee the tutor.

Other provinces and territories have their own statutes, formalities and time limits, and the older statutes in some of them use different terms again. A will made in one place is read in another according to that place's law, so no general statement about "Canada" is safe.

When no one was named

Where no appointment exists, none of these systems leaves a child without anybody. Each lets the court choose, on an application from a relative or other interested person, with the child's best interests as the test. What differs is the speed and who is at the table. The court cannot take account of what the parents would have wanted unless something shows it, and that is where a written appointment earns its place. Our guide on what happens without a will covers the wider picture for the money and property side.

A will is the usual home for the appointment, and our individual wills service is where a will with a guardian clause is made. Families with young children can see how it fits on our young families page.

Questions for families who move between provinces

A move changes which statute governs a child's guardianship, and an appointment written under one province's rules is read under another's once the family settles. These are the points a family may want to put to a professional in the new province:

  • Does the new province recognise an appointment made by will under the old one, and for how long does it take effect?
  • Is there a statutory form, a registry or a filing route for naming a guardian there, as there is for the Public Curator declaration in Quebec?
  • Do the wording and witnessing of the will meet the new province's formalities, including any rules on whether a handwritten or out-of-province will is accepted?
  • Does the person named as guardian live in the province, and would they have to accept the role in the way the new rules require?
  • If a family moves to or from Quebec, are the person-and-property roles of a tutor split differently from what the existing documents assume?
  • Which court would hear an application, and who must be served?

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.