Why two brokers report the same return differently
Two statements can show the same holdings over the same period and still report different returns, without either being wrong. The difference is usually the method, and once you know which one each platform uses, the numbers start to make sense.


You hold much the same investments with two providers. Over the same year, one statement reports a return of one figure and the other reports something noticeably different. Nothing looks broken, both platforms are reputable, and yet the two numbers will not reconcile however long you stare at them.
The usual explanation is not an error. It is that the two platforms are answering slightly different questions, using two long-established ways of measuring performance. This piece explains those two methods in general terms. It is about how figures are calculated and recorded, not about whether any investment is doing well or what you should hold.
The problem both methods are trying to solve
If you put money in once and never touched it again, measuring the return would be simple: compare what you ended with against what you started with. Real accounts are not like that. You add money, withdraw some, reinvest dividends and move cash between accounts. Each of those flows changes the balance without being a gain or a loss, and any return figure has to decide how to treat them. The two main methods decide differently.
Time-weighted return: how the investments did
A time-weighted return strips out the effect of your deposits and withdrawals. It breaks the period into segments at each cash flow, measures the growth within each segment, and links those segments together. The result describes how the underlying investments performed, regardless of when you happened to add or remove money.
That makes it the natural choice for comparing a portfolio against a benchmark, or one fund manager against another, because the manager did not choose when you topped up. Many platforms report this figure for that reason.
Money-weighted return: how your money did
A money-weighted return does the opposite. It takes the timing and size of every cash flow into account, so it describes the experience of the money you actually had invested. Put in a large sum just before a strong month and the figure rises; put it in just before a fall and the figure drops, even though the investments themselves behaved identically in both cases.
This is closer to the question most people are really asking about their own account: given what I paid in and when, how has my money done? It is usually calculated as an internal rate of return, and some platforms report this figure instead.
Why the two can diverge so far
When there are few cash flows, or the markets were steady, the two methods tend to land close together. They drift apart when large amounts moved in or out during a period of big price changes. A single sizeable deposit shortly before a sharp rise or fall is often enough to open a clear gap between them.
Other differences compound the effect:
- The period may not match. One statement may cover a calendar year and another a tax year, or a rolling twelve months to the statement date
- Fees may be treated differently. Some figures are shown before platform charges and some after
- Income may be handled differently. Dividends paid out as cash and dividends reinvested can be counted in different ways
- Currency can shift the result. A holding priced in one currency and reported in another carries exchange movements into the figure
- Transfers can reset the history. When holdings move between platforms, the receiving provider may treat the transfer date as the start, losing the earlier record
Put two or three of those together with different methods and it would be surprising if the figures did match.
What to check before comparing
Before concluding that one platform is right and the other is wrong, it helps to establish the basics for each figure:
- Which method it uses, time-weighted or money-weighted
- The exact start and end dates it covers
- Whether it is before or after fees
- How dividends and other income are counted
- Which currency it is expressed in
Most providers explain this in the notes to a statement or in their help pages, though it can take some finding.
One consistent basis beats several good ones
The deeper issue is that no combined picture can be built from figures calculated on different bases. Adding a time-weighted figure from one provider to a money-weighted figure from another produces a number that describes nothing at all. A consolidated view only makes sense when every holding is measured from the same underlying record of transactions, prices and cash flows, calculated the same way.
That is the thinking behind our portfolio tracker: holdings are imported from the statements your providers already issue and brought into one record, so returns can be looked at across holdings on a single consistent basis rather than stitched together from each platform's own figures.
The record matters to more people than you
A clear, consistent record of what was bought, when, and for how much is useful long after the question of this year's return has faded. Should someone else ever need to understand your investments, an executor or a family member, they will be working from whatever records exist. Our guide on what happens to an estate without a will touches on why a complete and current record of what someone owned matters to the people who have to deal with it.
So when two statements disagree, treat it as a question about method rather than a sign of a mistake. Find out how each figure was built, compare like with like, and keep one record of your own that does not depend on any single platform's way of counting.

