Estate Planning

Why an OCI card holder's will is not an NRI's will

TheWILL.ai Team

An OCI card and NRI status answer two different questions, and a will drafted for one status can leave the other's assets in a country nobody planned for.

Why an OCI card holder's will is not an NRI's will

Two people can each hold a document connecting them to India and still be answering completely different questions about it. One is asking who counts as a person of Indian origin for immigration and civil purposes. The other is asking who counts as a resident for tax and regulatory purposes. A will written as if the two were the same status tends to describe assets and categories that do not match either answer.

What follows is general information about the distinction between the two statuses and why it matters for a will. It is not a way to determine your own status or draft a will around it, because that depends on your specific facts, on the rules of every country where you hold assets, and on how those rules interact, none of which an article can see.

Two labels, two different jobs

Overseas Citizen of India status is a civil and immigration category. It is granted to certain people of Indian origin (or their spouses, subject to conditions) and gives lifelong visa-free entry along with a defined set of civil and economic rights, short of full citizenship and short of voting rights. It answers the question "what is your relationship to India as a country", and it does not change on its own from one year to the next.

Non-Resident Indian status is a tax and regulatory residency category, assessed under India's tax and foreign exchange rules by counting days spent in the country in a given financial year. It answers the question "how does India currently tax and regulate you", and unlike OCI status it can and does change: enough days back in India in a given year can shift a person out of NRI status entirely, without any card, application or announcement.

A person can hold OCI status and never qualify as an NRI in a given year. A person can qualify as an NRI without ever applying for OCI, if they hold Indian citizenship and simply live and work abroad. The two statuses are assessed by different tests, answer different questions, and can point in different directions for the same individual in the same year.

Where a will trips over the gap

A will is usually drafted against one clear picture of a person's status and assets. When OCI and NRI status diverge, that picture can be wrong in either direction.

Some asset categories in India are governed by rules that reference residency status specifically, including how certain holdings can be acquired, held or repatriated. A will drafted on the assumption that OCI status settles the residency question can describe an asset as freely disposable when the residency-specific rule that actually governs it was never checked. The reverse also happens: a will drafted around NRI status can overlook that OCI status is what actually governs eligibility to continue holding a given category of property at all.

There is also the question of which country's succession rules apply to which asset, a separate question from either status. Immovable property in India is generally governed by Indian succession law regardless of where the owner lives or what card they hold, while assets held abroad may fall under the succession rules of the country where they sit. Neither OCI nor NRI status resolves that on its own; each is one input into a picture that also depends on asset location and applicable succession law.

Why "just write one will" undercounts the problem

A single will can name all a person's assets. What it cannot do by itself is make every clause enforceable everywhere those assets sit, or ensure the drafting reflects which regulatory rule actually governs which holding today rather than the rule that governed it when OCI status was granted, possibly years earlier.

This is a narrower version of a broader problem: someone holding assets across more than one country is holding them under more than one legal system, and a will drafted with only one of those systems in view tends to be silent, or wrong, about the parts it did not see. Our page on coordinated wills across more than one country sets out the wider version of that problem and what a will needs to account for when more than one jurisdiction is in play.

Check the status the asset actually depends on

Do not treat "I have an OCI card" or "I am an NRI this year" as though either one, alone, tells a will everything it needs to know about an Indian asset. Each status governs a different set of questions, one civil and one regulatory, and either can be the one that matters for a given holding.

If assets sit in more than one country, the will drafted for you needs to reflect the rule that actually governs each asset, not the status that is easiest to state. Our guide to choosing a will-writing service in India covers what a provider handling Indian assets should be checking before drafting a clause that touches them.

Neither status, on its own, tells a will everything it needs to know about an Indian asset. Confirm which one, OCI, NRI, both or neither, actually governs each holding this year, because that can differ from the status that applies to the person, and take the specific combination to a qualified professional in each relevant country before relying on the answer.

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.