Estate Planning

The two signatures that decide whether your will counts

TheWILL.ai Team

A will is signed twice over, once by the person making it and once by the people who watched. Years later, when nobody who was in the room can be asked, those signatures on the page are most of what the probate registry has to go on.

The two signatures that decide whether your will countsThe two signatures that decide whether your will counts
This article coversUnited Kingdom - England and WalesUnited Kingdom - England and Wales

A will made in the ordinary way in England and Wales carries two kinds of signature. One belongs to the person making it. The other belongs to the witnesses who watched them do it. They are made in the same few minutes, often at the same table, but they do very different jobs, and the second one tends to matter most at a moment nobody at the table is thinking about: after the person who signed first has died.

England and Wales only; the rest of the UK, and other countries, handle signing differently. This is general information about how the law works, not advice on any particular will. If a will's signing is in doubt, a solicitor or probate professional who has seen the document is the right person to ask.

The first signature: yours

The Wills Act 1837 asks for the will to be signed by the person making it, whom the law calls the testator. What counts as a signature is broader than many people expect. The courts have accepted initials, a mark such as a cross, and a signature written somewhere other than the foot of the page, provided the person intended it to give effect to the will. Since the Administration of Justice Act 1982, which applies where the testator died on or after 1 January 1983, the signature has not had to sit at the end of the document.

Two variations come up more often than people realise. Someone who cannot physically sign, because of illness or injury, can direct another person to sign on their behalf, in their presence. And a testator who signed before the witnesses arrived can acknowledge that signature to them afterwards, as long as both witnesses are there together when they do.

Where the person signing was blind, could not read, or had someone else sign for them, the probate registry will usually want to be satisfied that they knew and approved what the will said. That is not a separate formality at the signing. It is a question the registry asks later, and it is much easier to answer if the will itself records that it was read over to the person before they signed.

The second signature: the witnesses

The witnesses sign to show that they saw the testator sign, or saw them acknowledge a signature already on the page. They are not confirming that they read the will, agree with it, or know what is in it, and there is no need for them to. What they are vouching for is an event, not a document.

That is why who they are matters. A witness has to be able to see the signing, so a person who is blind cannot act as one. Nor can someone who, at the time, lacked the capacity to understand what they were witnessing. The statute sets no minimum age, but a witness who may have to give an account of the signing years later needs to be someone capable of doing so, which is part of why adult, independent witnesses are the usual practice. And a witness who is also a beneficiary, or is married to or in a civil partnership with one, keeps the will valid but generally loses their own gift under it, which is the subject of an earlier post in this series.

What happens to those signatures at probate

When a will is submitted for probate, nobody from the signing is usually asked to appear. The probate registry looks at the document itself, and one short paragraph does most of the work: the attestation clause. This is the wording near the witnesses' signatures that says, in substance, that the will was signed by the testator in the joint presence of both witnesses, who then signed in the testator's presence. A will made through our individual wills service comes with instructions for witnessing it, which is where that wording and the order of signing are set out.

The law does not require an attestation clause, but its effect is considerable. Where a will carries a proper one and appears to have been signed correctly, the courts presume that it was, and the Court of Appeal has said that only the strongest evidence will displace that presumption. In one well-known case the presumption held even though the witnesses themselves said they could not remember the signing at all.

Where the clause is missing, or does not describe what the law requires, or something about the will raises a doubt, the registry can ask for sworn evidence of how it was signed, normally from one of the witnesses. That is the point at which the practical value of a witness becomes clear. A witness who can be found, remembers the occasion and is willing to give evidence can resolve the question quickly. A witness who has died, moved abroad or cannot be traced leaves the registry looking for other evidence, such as someone else who was present, and the estate waits while it does.

The signatures after the signing

The same two signatures matter again whenever the will is changed. An alteration made after the will was signed, whether a crossed-out name or a figure written in the margin, generally has no effect unless it is itself signed by the testator and witnessed in the same way. A handwritten correction that nobody witnessed usually leaves the will reading as it did before. The main exception is where the original words can no longer be read by ordinary means: those words then generally drop out, though a court can sometimes recover them, and whatever was written in their place still does not count.

The registry also looks at the physical document. A will with signs that something was once attached to it and later removed, such as staple holes with nothing in them, can prompt questions about whether a page is missing. That does not usually mean the will fails, but it means someone has to explain what happened, and that explanation is harder to give the longer ago the signing was.

Making the signing easy to prove later

Most of this comes down to one idea: a will is signed once but may need to be proved much later, by people who were not there. A few things tend to make that proof straightforward:

  • An attestation clause that describes what actually happened at the signing
  • Witnesses who are independent of the will, with their full names and addresses written under their signatures so they can be traced
  • No changes made to the document after it has been signed, unless they are signed and witnessed too
  • The signed original kept whole, rather than unstapled for copying

That list is worth running through before the will is signed rather than after it, while the witnesses are still easy to choose. Our guide to physical and digital will signatures sets out how signing requirements differ between jurisdictions, including where England and Wales still requires a physical signature.

Sources

  • Wills Act 1837, section 9 (signing and witnessing), section 15 (gifts to witnesses) and section 21 (alterations after execution)
  • Administration of Justice Act 1982, section 17 (the current form of section 9)
  • Non-Contentious Probate Rules 1987, rules 12 to 14 (evidence of due execution, knowledge and approval, and alterations)
  • Sherrington v Sherrington [2005] EWCA Civ 326 (the presumption of due execution)
  • Channon v Perkins [2005] EWCA Civ 1808 (the presumption where the witnesses cannot recall the signing)
  • Re Gibson [1949] P 434 (a blind person cannot act as a witness)

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.