Estate Planning

Property abroad and a will in England and Wales: one will or two?

TheWILL.ai Team

A will made in England and Wales can be revoked by a later will signed abroad. How English law treats foreign wills and foreign land, and when people keep one will or two.

Property abroad and a will in England and Wales: one will or two?
This article coversUnited Kingdom - England and WalesUnited Kingdom - England and Wales

Section 20 of the Wills Act 1837 names a short list of ways a will made in England and Wales can be revoked. One of them is "another will or codicil". It says nothing about where that other will has to be signed, and since 1964 the Wills Act 1963 has treated a wide range of wills signed abroad as properly made. That is the whole reason a holiday home, an inherited plot or a foreign account can quietly undo a carefully drafted English will.

What follows is general information on how the law of England and Wales treats wills and property abroad, not legal or tax advice. It cannot predict what another country's law will do with an estate, and every country where assets sit has its own say.

What section 20 lets a later will do

Under section 20, a will or codicil can be revoked by marriage (the "as aforesaid" in the section, which points back to section 18), by a later will or codicil, by a signed writing declaring an intention to revoke, or by destroying it with that intention.

A later will does not need to mention the earlier one to revoke it. A standard clause in professionally drafted wills, in England and in many other countries, revokes "all former wills and testamentary dispositions". A clause in those words, read without anything to limit it, reaches every earlier will the person has made, wherever it was made. A clause is not even needed: where a later will deals with the same property differently, it generally displaces the earlier one so far as the two cannot both stand.

When English law accepts a will signed abroad

The Wills Act 1963 sets out when a will is treated as "properly executed" for the purposes of English law. Section 1 accepts a will if the way it was signed and witnessed followed the internal law of any one of these:

  • the territory where it was signed;
  • the territory where the person was domiciled, either when they signed or when they died;
  • the territory where they had their habitual residence at either of those times;
  • a state of which they were a national at either of those times.

Section 2 adds more routes. Under section 2(1)(b), a will is treated as properly executed so far as it disposes of immovable property if it followed the internal law of the place where that property is situated. Under section 2(1)(c), a will is treated as properly executed so far as it revokes an earlier will if it followed any law by which that earlier will would itself have been treated as properly executed.

Put those together and the risk is plain. A notarial will signed in Spain, France or Portugal is very likely to be formally valid in English eyes, and if its revocation clause is drawn widely, it can revoke an English will made years before. The same is true in the other direction: an English will signed after a foreign one, with the usual revocation clause, can revoke the foreign will as far as English law is concerned. What the foreign country makes of that is a question for its own law.

Land abroad follows the law of the place where it sits

English conflict of laws has long drawn a line between movable property (money, shares, personal belongings) and immovable property (land and buildings). Succession to movables is generally governed by the law of the person's domicile at death. Succession to immovables is generally governed by the law of the place where the land is, often called the lex situs. This is a common law rule rather than a statutory one.

So an English will can leave a flat in another country, and an English court will accept its formal validity, but who actually inherits that flat, whether some relatives have a protected share, and what paperwork a local registry needs before it will record a new owner are all questions for the country where the flat stands. Many civil law countries give children, and sometimes a spouse, a reserved share of the estate that a will cannot remove, a rule usually called forced heirship. Local formalities and a local grant or notarial deed are commonly needed as well.

The EU Succession Regulation and a choice of law

Most EU member states apply Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, usually called the EU Succession Regulation or Brussels IV. The United Kingdom never took part in it, and it is not part of the law of England and Wales. It still matters to anyone living here with property in a member state that applies it, such as Spain, France, Portugal or Poland, because it is what those countries' courts and notaries use.

Article 22 lets a person choose, as the law to govern their succession as a whole, the law of a state whose nationality they hold, either at the time of making the choice or at death. The choice has to be made expressly in a will or similar document, or be shown by its terms. Article 20 says that a law chosen or identified under the Regulation applies even when it is not the law of a member state, which is why a British national can make that choice. Whether a choice suits a particular estate, and how it should be worded, are questions for lawyers in the countries concerned.

Four estates, four different problems

A retired couple with a villa in Spain. A former bookshop owner and her husband, both living in Kent, made English mirror wills in 2019. When they bought a villa on the Spanish coast, the notary suggested each sign a Spanish will covering Spanish assets. If those Spanish wills carry an unlimited revocation clause, the English wills may be revoked, leaving their English house and savings to the intestacy rules. Couples in this position commonly have each will limited expressly to the assets in its own country, and have each lawyer see the other's draft.

A young family with an inherited share of a house in Lithuania. A bus driver in Leicester inherited a third of her grandparents' house near Kaunas, alongside two cousins. Her English will leaves everything to her husband, and to their two children if he dies first. Because the share is Lithuanian land, Lithuanian law and procedure will have a large part to play in who takes it, and Lithuanian law protects a compulsory share for certain close relatives. She may find that a Lithuanian notarial will, or a choice of law, is what a Lithuanian notary expects to see. Either way, the English will's residuary gift does not settle the Lithuanian share on its own.

A widowed father with a flat in Lagos. A retired printer in Croydon owns a flat in Lagos that he lets to tenants. Nigeria is not bound by the EU Regulation, so the choice-of-law route in Article 22 has no part to play. Under English conflict rules the flat goes by Nigerian law, and his children will probably need a grant or other recognition in Nigeria before the flat can be transferred. If he has a Nigerian will as well as an English one, the dates and the revocation clauses in each decide which survives.

A freelance photographer with a US brokerage account. After most of her thirties working in New York, a photographer moved back to Bristol, keeping her American brokerage account. She made a simple will in New York before she left, and last year an English one with the usual clause revoking all former wills. For English purposes the New York will is probably gone, and the account, being movable property, is governed by the law of her domicile. The broker, though, will set its own requirements before releasing the account to her executors, and those can involve US paperwork even when the English will is perfectly clear.

When one will is enough, and when a second one is common

For many people, a single English will is enough. Someone domiciled in England and Wales whose foreign holdings are bank or investment accounts, rather than land, may find that the English grant of probate is accepted abroad, or can be resealed or supplemented without a separate will.

A second will is more common where there is land abroad, or where local notaries and registries work far more easily with a local will. Where two wills exist, the recurring features are these: each is limited to named assets or to assets in one country, each revocation clause is drawn narrowly so that it revokes only earlier wills about the same assets, and the executors and lawyers in each country know the other will exists. Tools that coordinate wills across jurisdictions from one platform are built for exactly this kind of arrangement, and our page on wills in more than one country sets out how such arrangements are usually put together.

Both wills also have to be found. A foreign will that the family never learns about cannot be proved, and an English one sitting unknown in an archive can be missed just as easily. A service that helps make sure a will is found when it matters addresses that part of the problem. For more on how English law approaches wills generally, including formal validity and revocation, see our United Kingdom legal guide.

What the English will can settle, and what it cannot

An English will can deal with everything a person owns in England and Wales, and with their movable property wherever it is held, so long as they are domiciled here at death. It can appoint executors, set up trusts for children, and state in terms which assets it covers and which earlier wills it revokes. It can be drafted so that it sits alongside a foreign will instead of cancelling it, and under the Wills Act 1963 it is likely to be recognised as formally valid in a wide range of places.

What it cannot do is override the law of another country about land in that country. It cannot remove a reserved share that local law gives to children or a spouse, it cannot make a foreign land registry accept a transfer without the local grant or deed that registry requires, and it cannot stop a later will signed abroad from revoking it if that later will is drafted too widely. It also cannot tell anyone that a second will exists. Where the English will's reach ends for a given family depends on which countries hold their property, what that property is and who is left behind, and it is a point for a qualified professional in England and Wales and in every other country involved.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.