Estate Planning

Irish residents with property abroad: one will or two?

TheWILL.ai Team

For people living in Ireland with a home, a pension or an account in another country, whether one will or two works better depends on Irish succession law and on the law of the place where the asset sits.

Irish residents with property abroad: one will or two?
This article coversIrelandIreland

Ireland wrote the Hague Convention on the form of wills into its own succession statute in 1965, so an Irish court is unusually generous about accepting a will signed abroad. Validity of form, though, is not the end of it: a will can still collide with a second will, with the law of the country where a house sits, or with a spouse's fixed share under Irish law.

This piece describes the general position under Irish law and touches on other systems only in outline. It is general information, not legal or tax advice, and nothing in it is a recommendation about any particular estate.

What the Succession Act 1965 asks of any will

Under section 78 of the Succession Act 1965, a will is valid if it is in writing, signed at the foot or end by the testator (or by someone in their presence and at their direction), with that signature made or acknowledged before two witnesses present at the same time, each of whom then signs.

Part VIII of the Act deals with wills that have a foreign element. Section 102 treats a will as valid in form if it complies with the internal law of any one of several places: where it was made, a nationality the testator held, a place where they were domiciled or habitually resident (either when they made it or when they died), and, for land, the place where the land is.

How a later will can undo an earlier one

Section 85(2) lists the ways a will is revoked, and the first of them is "another will or codicil duly executed". Many professionally drafted wills begin with a clause cancelling every earlier will. If someone signs a Portuguese will for a holiday flat and, two years later, signs an Irish will containing that clause without limiting it to Irish property, the Irish will can sweep away the Portuguese one. Section 102(2) reinforces the point from the other side: a revoking will is valid in form if it satisfies any law under which the revoked will was valid.

Silence is no protection either: a later will that disposes of the same property inconsistently can displace the earlier gift. The usual way around both hazards, where people keep two wills, is to limit each will expressly to the assets in one country and to word each revocation clause so that it leaves the other will standing.

Section 85(1) adds a distinctly Irish trap. Marriage, or entry into a civil partnership, revokes an earlier will unless it was made in contemplation of that marriage or partnership.

Where the Irish fixed shares reach

Part IX of the Act gives a surviving spouse or civil partner a legal right share that a will cannot override: half the estate where there are no children, a third where there are (sections 111 and 111A). Section 117 separately allows a child to ask the court for provision where a parent has failed in their moral duty to provide for them, with a strict six-month limit from the first grant of representation under section 117(6).

Section 109(2) defines the estate for these purposes as property the testator was entitled to for an interest not ending on death, after debts and expenses. How far those rules reach land outside Ireland is a conflict-of-laws question, and the traditional common law approach is that succession to land is governed by the law of the place where it sits. Our Irish legal guide sets out the domestic rules; a foreign home may follow very different ones.

Holiday homes, inheritances and accounts abroad

A couple in Cork with an apartment in the Algarve. Ireland did not opt in to the EU Succession Regulation 650/2012 (recital 82 records that it is not bound), but Portugal is. A Portuguese notary or court will look at the estate through the Regulation's rules, which start from the law of the deceased's habitual residence and allow a person to choose the law of a nationality. How those rules interact with Irish conflict rules for land is technical, and Portuguese law includes forced heirship protections that Irish law does not. Couples in this position commonly keep a Portuguese will limited to the apartment alongside an Irish will for everything else.

A retired librarian who inherited a house in Northern Ireland from an aunt. Same island, different jurisdiction: Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom and has its own succession law and probate system. It has no legal right share of the Irish kind, and dealing with the house usually involves a grant or recognition of a grant through the courts there. One Irish will can cover it, but administration still runs through two systems.

A sound engineer in her late twenties with a workplace pension from four years in Germany. Occupational schemes often pay death benefits under their own rules, to a spouse or partner or to someone the member named, so the scheme's paperwork, easily forgotten once the payslips stop, may decide where the money goes rather than any will.

A widowed farmer whose son in Boston holds a joint US account with her. In many US states a joint account with a right of survivorship passes to the surviving holder outside the will. Irish law has its own long-running case law on whether money in a joint account was really meant as a gift, so the answer is not always the same on both sides of the Atlantic. What the farmer's Irish will says about "all my money" may therefore reach less than she expects.

Deciding between a single will and separate ones

One will has real advantages: one document, one set of executors, no risk of two revocation clauses colliding. It tends to suit people whose foreign assets are movable (bank accounts, investments) or sit in a common law system such as Northern Ireland, where an Irish-form will is more easily recognised.

Separate wills are commonly chosen where there is land in a civil law country, where local notaries expect a document in their own language and form, or where a foreign grant would otherwise be slow. The cost is coordination: two sets of advisers and two documents that must stay consistent whenever either changes. A platform that coordinates wills across jurisdictions keeps both documents in view, and recording each property and account in an asset tracker makes it clearer which will covers what.

Making sure the right will turns up

A will that nobody knows about cannot be proved. Ireland has no statutory central wills register, so family members often learn of a foreign will only when a notary or bank asks for it. Noting where each will is held, who drew it up and which assets it covers, and using a service that helps make sure a will is found when it matters, reduces the chance of an overlooked will surfacing after the estate has been distributed.

What the couple found when they looked again

The Cork couple had made mutual Irish wills when their children were small and bought the Algarve apartment fifteen years later. When they looked again, the question was not really "one or two" but whether their Irish wills, with their broad revocation clauses, would quietly cancel anything they signed in Portugal, and how a Portuguese notary would treat an Irish will that never mentioned the apartment. Each of those answers turned on a different body of law. Every estate with a foot in two countries sits differently, depending on where its assets are, what they are and who inherits, and the Irish side and the foreign side each call for a qualified professional's view.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.