Estate Planning

Pakistanis with assets abroad: one will or two?

TheWILL.ai Team

Many Pakistanis hold a flat, an account or a house outside Pakistan. Whether one will covers it all, or a second is made abroad, depends on who they are and where each asset sits.

Pakistanis with assets abroad: one will or two?
This article coversPakistanPakistan

In Pakistan, the first question about any will is not where it was signed but whose will it is. For a Muslim, the rule of decision on wills and succession is Muslim personal law; for a Christian, and for some others, it is the Succession Act 1925. That split shapes everything that follows once a family owns something beyond Pakistan's borders.

This is general information about the law in Pakistan, written for readers who live there and also own property or accounts in other countries. It is not legal or tax advice, and it does not describe the law of any other country in detail.

Which law governs a Pakistani will

Section 2 of the West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act 1962 provides that, notwithstanding any custom or usage, questions of succession, wills and legacies are decided by Muslim personal law where the parties are Muslims. Part VI of the Succession Act 1925, which sets out the formal rules for making and revoking wills, does not apply to testamentary succession of Muslims at all (section 58(1)).

For a Pakistan Christian the position is different. Part VI does apply, so a will is executed under section 63: the testator signs or marks it, and two or more witnesses attest it, each having seen the signature or received the testator's acknowledgement of it.

The third a Muslim can leave by will

Under Muslim personal law as applied in Pakistan, a bequest (wasiyyat) is generally limited to one third of what remains after funeral costs and debts. The other two thirds pass to the heirs in fixed shares. Under the Hanafi rules that most Sunni Pakistanis follow, a bequest to someone who is already a legal heir takes effect only if the other heirs consent after the death, and a bequest beyond the third needs the same consent. Shia rules differ on some of this, which is one reason the school of law a family follows is worth knowing.

Take a couple in Lahore with two children and a flat in Istanbul that they let to visitors. Their Pakistani wills can only do so much: the third is small, and the shares are fixed. The Istanbul flat raises a separate question, because Turkish law governs succession to immovable property in Turkey, and Turkish law reserves shares of an estate for close family. Some families in this position make a second will before a Turkish notary for the flat alone.

Land abroad follows the law where it sits

Pakistan applies the same logic to its own soil. Section 5(1) of the Succession Act provides that succession to immovable property in Pakistan is regulated by Pakistani law, wherever the deceased was domiciled. Other countries commonly say the same about land within their borders, and they are not bound to apply Islamic shares to it.

A retired professor in Islamabad owns a house in Birmingham where his son now lives. If he dies without a will valid in England, English intestacy rules decide who takes the house, and those rules do not follow Islamic fractions. A division along the lines of Muslim personal law would reach the house only if a will accepted in England set it out. The son living there does not, by itself, give him a claim to it.

A young textile designer in Karachi with a US brokerage account faces a different mechanism. Many US brokerage accounts pass by a transfer-on-death beneficiary designation that sits outside any will, and where there is none, the account may need a grant in the relevant US state before it is released. A designation made years ago, perhaps naming a sibling, can quietly override what a later Pakistani will says.

When one will cancels another

Wills rarely stay alone. A standard clause in a new will revoking "all former wills" can revoke a will made earlier in another country, unless it is limited to property in one place. Leave the clause out and inconsistency can still do it: a later will that deals with the same property differently can override the earlier one.

For Christians, section 70 of the Succession Act allows revocation by another will or codicil, by a written declaration executed like a will, or by destroying it with the intention of revoking it, and section 69 adds that marriage revokes a will. Families keeping two wills commonly describe in each one the assets it covers and state that it leaves the other untouched. Our asset tracker records assets in one portfolio, which makes that list easier to keep current.

Getting assets released at home and abroad

Section 213 of the Succession Act requires probate or letters of administration before a right as executor or legatee can be established in a Pakistani court, but subsection (2) excludes wills made by Muslims. In practice, heirs of a Muslim estate usually obtain a succession certificate from the District Judge under section 372 for debts and securities, or letters of administration for wider assets. In the Islamabad Capital Territory, the Letters of Administration and Succession Certificates Act 2020 also allows applications through NADRA's succession facilitation units.

A Christian widow in Karachi still has an account in Canada from the years she worked in Toronto. Her will is governed by the Succession Act, and in Pakistan it would normally be proved through probate. The Canadian bank will usually want its own paperwork as well, which may mean a grant from a Canadian court or the resealing of the Pakistani one. Section 228 works the other way round, allowing a Pakistani court to grant letters of administration on an authenticated copy of a will already proved abroad. Our guide to wills in Pakistan sets out the domestic steps in more detail.

Where this leaves a family with ties to two countries

Nothing in Pakistani law forbids a second will made abroad, and for land or accounts in another country it is often how families make sure the local courts have something they can work with. The risk is in the joins between the two wills: a revocation clause drafted without the other in mind, a fixed share that a foreign court may not apply, a beneficiary form nobody remembers. Our page on wills in more than one country looks at how these arrangements tend to fit together, and the will registry helps make sure every will is found when it is needed.

The right number of wills, and how they should be worded, turns on the countries involved, the kind of assets, the family's faith and school of law, and their circumstances at the time. That makes it something to check with a qualified professional in Pakistan and in each other country where property is held.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.