Estate Planning

South African wills and offshore assets: one will or two?

TheWILL.ai Team

South African residents with a flat, a pension or an investment account overseas often ask whether one will can cover it all, or whether a separate offshore will is the safer way to keep things straight.

South African wills and offshore assets: one will or two?
This article coversSouth AfricaSouth Africa

A couple in Durban bought a one-bedroom flat in London when their daughter started university there. Their South African will, signed years earlier, leaves "everything" to each other and then to the children. It says nothing about London, and nobody in the family has asked what an English executor would make of it.

This article is general information about South African law. It is not legal or tax advice, and it cannot tell you how the rules apply to your own estate or to any country other than South Africa.

What a South African will needs on paper

The Wills Act 7 of 1953 sets out the formalities in section 2(1)(a). The will is signed at the end by the testator (or by someone else in their presence and at their direction), in the presence of two or more competent witnesses who are present at the same time. The witnesses sign in the presence of the testator and of each other, and every page other than the last is signed as well. Section 1 defines a competent witness as someone aged fourteen or over who is not incompetent to give evidence in court.

When the formalities are not met

Two provisions soften those rules. The first is section 2(3). If a court is satisfied that a document drafted or executed by a person who has since died was intended to be their will, it orders the Master to accept it as a will even though it does not comply with all the formalities. That is a court application after death, with the cost and delay that implies, not a substitute for signing properly.

The second is section 3bis, which deals with wills made under other systems. A will is not invalid merely because of its form if that form complies with the internal law of the place where it was executed, or where the testator was domiciled or habitually resident when signing or at death, or of a state of which the testator was then a citizen. For immovable property, a will is also not invalid on form grounds if it complies with the law of the place where the property is. So a will signed in Mauritius in the Mauritian form, by a retired court interpreter who later moves back to Pietermaritzburg, is not struck down in South Africa simply because it was not signed and witnessed in the South African way.

How a later will can cancel an earlier one

Under South African common law, a later will revokes an earlier one to the extent that the two cannot stand together, and a clause expressly revoking "all previous wills" revokes the lot. Section 2A of the Wills Act adds a further route: a court can declare a will, or part of it, revoked where the testator made a written indication on it, did something apparent from its face, or drafted another document intending to revoke it. Section 3bis(1)(d) deals with the form of a revoking will: so far as it revokes an earlier will, it is not invalid on form grounds if it complies with the law under which that earlier will was itself valid. A will signed abroad can therefore revoke a South African one without following South African formalities.

Take a young actuary who spent two years in Brisbane on a working holiday and signed a short Australian will before coming home, then made a new South African will at 30 with a standard revocation clause. The new will may well have cancelled the Australian one completely. Whether that matters depends partly on the asset: Australian superannuation is paid out by the fund's trustee, and whether it passes under a will at all depends on the fund's rules and any nomination held by the fund.

The offshore will habit

For these reasons, a widely used arrangement among South Africans with assets overseas is two wills: a South African will for assets in South Africa, and a separate "offshore" or foreign will for assets in a named country, often drawn up under that country's law. Each typically states which assets it covers and limits its revocation clause to earlier wills dealing with the same assets, so that signing one does not wipe out the other. Each will also commonly acknowledges that the other exists.

Two wills are not automatically better than one. They add a second document to keep current, and two sets of executors who may need to talk to each other. Some people with a single modest account abroad keep one South African will and deal with the foreign asset through its local procedure. Keeping the two in step is the work that coordinating wills across jurisdictions from one platform is designed to help with.

Offshore property and offshore rules

Section 3bis(1)(b) is only about form, but it points at a principle most legal systems share: succession to land and buildings is generally governed by the law of the place where they are. A will that is entirely valid in South Africa can still run into the rules of the country where the property is: reserved shares for children, local formalities, or a local grant of authority before anything can be sold.

Movable assets can raise the same practical point. A widowed shop owner holding shares through a platform administered in Jersey may find that the platform wants its own proof of who is entitled to deal with the holding, whatever the South African executor has been appointed to do. Having the assets listed in one place, with the country and institution for each, is what recording assets in one portfolio is for. The broader South African position on wills and intestacy is in our South Africa legal guide.

Getting the right will to the Master

In South Africa, deceased estates are administered under the supervision of the Master of the High Court. Section 8(1) of the Administration of Estates Act 66 of 1965 requires anyone holding a document that is or purports to be a will to deliver it to the Master as soon as they learn of the testator's death. That duty only works if somebody knows where the will is, and it does nothing for a foreign will filed with a lawyer overseas whom no one in South Africa has heard of. A record of where each will is held, and which assets each covers, is the gap a service that helps make sure a will is found when it matters is meant to close.

What the couple still have to settle

For the Durban couple, the questions are concrete: whether their South African will, with its broad wording, is the document an English executor would be asked to prove; whether a separate English will for the flat would be drafted to leave their South African will untouched, and the other way round; and whether their daughter, living in London, would know where either document is kept. No two families reach the same answers, because the countries, the assets and the people differ, and each set of answers is one to test with a qualified professional in South Africa and wherever else the property is.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.