Estate Planning

The will that accidentally disinherits a stepchild

TheWILL.ai Team

A couple in a second marriage sign matching wills that leave everything to each other and then to all three children. Nobody meant to cut anyone out. Years later one of those children receives nothing, and every step that got there was lawful.

The will that accidentally disinherits a stepchildThe will that accidentally disinherits a stepchild
This article coversUnited Kingdom - England and WalesUnited Kingdom - England and Wales

Mark and Helen married in their forties. Mark had a daughter, Amy, from his first marriage. Helen had two sons. They bought a house together, blended the household, and a few years in they made wills. The wills matched: each left everything to the other, and on the second death the estate was to be split equally between all three children, named one by one.

Mark died first. Helen inherited everything, as both of them had intended. Eight years later Helen died, and Amy received nothing. Every document was valid, and every step followed from them. The plan simply stopped being a plan the moment Mark died, and nobody had noticed.

What a mirror will actually is

Matching wills of this kind are usually called mirror wills. Couples tend to think of them as one shared decision. In England and Wales they are not. They are two separate documents, and each one can be changed or replaced by the person who signed it, at any time, without telling the other, which is how mirror wills work by design.

While both people are alive that rarely matters. After the first death it matters a great deal. The survivor now owns everything outright, including whatever came from the partner who died, and the survivor's will is the only document that decides where it goes next. The line naming a stepchild is there because the survivor chose to keep it there, and it stays only for as long as they keep choosing to.

Three ways the stepchild drops out

In Helen's case it was a new will. In the years after Mark died her sons were closer to hand, Amy lived abroad, and the relationship thinned. Helen rewrote her will to leave everything to her own two sons. She was entitled to. Mark's share of the house and savings went with it, because by then it was simply Helen's money.

The second route involves no decision at all. In England and Wales, getting married or entering a civil partnership normally revokes an existing will, unless the will was made in expectation of that particular marriage. A survivor who remarries and does not make a new will may die without one. The intestacy rules then give the new spouse a fixed sum and a share of anything above it, with the survivor's own children sharing the rest, and in a smaller estate the new spouse can take everything. Stepchildren who were never adopted do not appear in those rules at all. The guide to what happens when someone dies without a will sets out who does inherit.

The third route is in the wording. Wills that leave the residue to "my children" or "our children" rather than naming each child can be read as meaning the testator's own children, which in a blended family is exactly the group that leaves someone out. Naming each child, as Mark and Helen did, closes that gap but not the other two.

The house can bypass the will completely

A jointly owned home adds another layer. If a couple own the house as joint tenants, the survivor becomes the sole owner automatically on the first death, whatever either will says. How the house is held is usually shown on the title register, not in either will.

Why a court claim is a poor safety net

A stepchild who has been cut out is not always without a route. The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 lets certain people ask a court for reasonable financial provision from an estate, and that can include someone the deceased treated as a child of the family, whether through a marriage, a civil partnership or a family in which they stood in the role of a parent. But a claim is not an inheritance. It normally has to be brought within six months of the grant of probate or letters of administration, it depends heavily on the facts, adult claimants who are financially independent often find it hard, and it usually means one side of a family taking the other to court. Most people who made mirror wills meant to avoid exactly that.

What couples in blended families tend to discuss

There are arrangements designed for this situation, and each involves a trade-off between protecting the stepchildren and leaving the survivor free to manage their own life.

  • Trusts in the first will. Instead of leaving everything outright, each partner can leave some or all of their share on trust, often giving the survivor the right to live in the home or receive the income for life, with the capital passing to named children afterwards. The survivor cannot then redirect that share, which is the point and also the cost.
  • Mutual wills. These are wills backed by an agreement that neither will be changed after the first death. They are less common than people expect, the agreement has to be clearly proved, and they can bind the survivor more tightly than either partner intended. The survivor can still make a new will, but the property covered by the agreement is held on trust for the agreed beneficiaries.
  • Naming every child, and writing the remarriage question down. A couple can record their wishes about what happens if the survivor remarries, and a survivor who later plans to remarry can make a will expressed to be in expectation of that marriage, so the marriage does not revoke it. Neither makes the survivor's later choices binding, but they make the intention clear.

Which of these fits depends on the family, the assets and how much freedom each partner wants the other to keep, which is a conversation to have with a qualified professional rather than something a general article can settle. The blended families page lists the questions people usually raise in that conversation.

The question to ask before signing

Mark and Helen's wills did what they were written to do. They just assumed Helen would never change hers. The useful question for any couple with children from earlier relationships is what the plan should be if the survivor, years later and in very different circumstances, is no longer the person who signed it.

Sources

This article is general information about how wills commonly work in England and Wales. It is not legal advice, and the rules differ in Scotland, Northern Ireland and other countries.

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.