What makes a will validly signed in England and Wales?
Section 9 of the Wills Act 1837 sets four conditions in one sentence, and "two witnesses" is the one part almost everyone already knows. The other three are where wills actually fail, and England and Wales still has no safety net when they do.
Section 9 of the Wills Act 1837, as it now reads following the Administration of Justice Act 1982, sets out four separate conditions for a will to be validly executed. Most people can name one of them: two witnesses. The other three are where a properly intentioned will most often comes unstuck, and unlike some of the jurisdictions this article's siblings cover, England and Wales has no general power to forgive the mistake.
This article is general information rather than legal advice. Whether a particular will was validly executed depends on facts about how it was signed and witnessed that a reader cannot settle from an article. If you have doubts about a will's execution, take it to a qualified professional rather than relying on the pattern below.
Four conditions, not one
The section reads as a single sentence, but it is doing four jobs. The will must be signed by the testator, or by someone else in the testator's presence and at their direction. The testator must intend, by that signature, to give effect to the will as their last will. The signature must be made, or acknowledged as already made, in the presence of two or more witnesses who are both present at the same time. And each witness must then attest and sign the will, or acknowledge their own earlier signature, in the testator's presence.
The third condition is the one that trips up more wills than any other, and it is worth separating carefully from the fourth. What section 9 insists on is that both witnesses are present together, in the same room, at the moment the testator signs or acknowledges the signature. What it does not insist on is that the witnesses sign at the same time as each other: paragraph (d) requires each witness to sign in the presence of the testator "but not necessarily in the presence of any other witness", so two witnesses who watched the testator sign together and then added their own signatures on different days, each with the testator present, have executed the will properly. What fails is a will assembled by post, where the testator signs alone and each witness adds a signature in their own time without the two of them ever having been present together for that signature. That document has not been validly executed under section 9 no matter how sincerely everyone involved intended it to be a will.
The witness who cannot also inherit
Section 15 adds a separate trap that has nothing to do with whether the will is valid. If a witness, or that witness's spouse or civil partner at the time of the will, is also a beneficiary under the will, the will itself remains valid, but the gift to that witness or their spouse fails unless the will was duly executed without that signature. Section 1 of the Wills Act 1968 disregards the interested witness's attestation if the will is duly executed without it and without the attestation of any other interested witness, so a third, disinterested witness can save the gift, but only where every interested signature is set aside at once and two good ones remain. Where two witnesses signed and one of them is the beneficiary, nothing rescues it. The clearest way this bites is in a blended household: a new partner who signs as a witness to help a testator finish the paperwork, without realising they have just cancelled their own gift under it.
The video-witnessing rule that no longer applies
During the pandemic, a temporary provision allowed the "presence" requirement in section 9 to be satisfied by video link rather than physical presence in the same room, for wills executed on or after 31 January 2020 and on or before 31 January 2024, that end date having been pushed back a further two years by a 2022 order. That window has closed. A will made after it needs the witnesses physically present with the testator; a will made during it, following the temporary rules correctly, remains validly executed on that basis, which is worth knowing if an older will in a family is ever questioned.
Formalities are not the whole test
This is the point the title of this article is built around, and it is worth stating plainly: correct execution under section 9 is necessary, but it has never been sufficient. A will signed by the testator in front of two independent witnesses, present together, none of them a beneficiary, can still fail for want of testamentary capacity, for want of knowledge and approval of the contents, or because of undue influence. Execution formalities answer only the mechanical question of whether the document was signed and witnessed correctly. They say nothing about whether the person signing understood and freely intended what they were signing.
Unlike Australia and some Canadian provinces, England and Wales has no general dispensing power that lets a court admit a document as a will despite a formalities defect, on the strength of clear evidence of testamentary intent. The Law Commission's report Modernising Wills Law, published on 16 May 2025, recommended introducing one, alongside a single capacity test drawn from the Mental Capacity Act 2005 and a reformed approach to undue influence, and it came with a draft Bill to replace the 1837 Act outright. A recommendation, even one with a Bill attached, is not yet law. Until Parliament acts on it, a will that fails section 9 in England and Wales is not a will, whatever the document plainly says the person wanted.
What a failed execution leads to
A will that was never validly executed is treated as if it never existed. The estate is then distributed under the intestacy rules, or under an earlier valid will if one exists, regardless of what the failed document said. That is a materially different outcome from the errors this cluster's Scottish and American entries describe, where an unwitnessed document can still be valid, only harder to prove.
What is worth checking
- Whether both witnesses were physically present together, and present with the testator, at the moment of signing
- Whether either witness, or their spouse or civil partner, is also a beneficiary under the will
- Whether a will made between 31 January 2020 and 31 January 2024 used the temporary video-witnessing provision, and did so correctly
Getting execution right the first time avoids all of this. You can start or review a will through our individual wills service, or with any provider or professional you prefer, and once it is signed our document vault keeps the executed original findable rather than lost in a drawer. Our guide on what happens without a will covers what intestacy actually leaves behind if execution goes wrong. If you are unsure whether an existing will was properly executed, take it to a qualified professional rather than guessing from this article.
Sources
- Wills Act 1837, section 9 (opens in a new tab), as substituted by the Administration of Justice Act 1982, legislation.gov.uk
- Wills Act 1837, section 15 (opens in a new tab), gifts to attesting witnesses, legislation.gov.uk
- Administration of Justice Act 1982, section 17 (opens in a new tab), substitution of section 9, legislation.gov.uk
- Wills Act 1968, section 1 (opens in a new tab), attestation by an interested witness disregarded, legislation.gov.uk
- Wills Act 1837 (Electronic Communications) (Amendment) (Coronavirus) Order 2020 (opens in a new tab), which inserted the temporary video-witnessing provision at section 9(2), legislation.gov.uk
- Wills Act 1837 (Electronic Communications) (Amendment) Order 2022 (opens in a new tab), article 2(2), which substituted 2024 for 2022 as the end date, legislation.gov.uk
- Modernising Wills Law (opens in a new tab), Law Commission of England and Wales, 16 May 2025, dispensing power and draft Bill
Written by
TheWILL.ai Team
The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.


