Estate Planning

Can you see the file behind a will in England and Wales?

TheWILL.ai Team

A grant of probate makes the will itself public, but the papers behind it are a separate question with a separate answer. Here is who is entitled to what, and the convention that governs the rest.

Can you see the file behind a will in England and Wales?
This article coversUnited Kingdom - England and WalesUnited Kingdom - England and Wales

A grant of probate turns a will into a public document that anybody may buy a copy of, which is the part of this most people already know and the part that helps them least. The question that actually gets asked after a funeral is narrower: not what the will says, but what the papers behind it say. Who was in the room. What the person was asked. Why a child was left out, and whether anyone wrote down the reason they gave.

This article describes the law of England and Wales as at October 2026. Scotland and Northern Ireland run separate statute books and separate courts, and the position below is not theirs. It is general information, not legal advice, and a live dispute about a will is one for a qualified professional.

Two documents, two rules

It helps to separate the two things that get called "the will file".

The first is the will. Until a grant issues, it is private, and nobody outside the executors has a right to read it. Once a grant of probate or letters of administration issues, the original is held by the court and section 125 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 provides for copies. In practice that means anybody at all can search the probate records online and order a copy for a fee set by the court service, whether they are family or not.

The second is the drafting file: the attendance notes, the instructions taken, the earlier drafts, the note of who else was present and what was said. Nothing makes that public. It never enters the court record, and a grant does not touch it.

The file belongs to the client, and the client's rights pass on

The drafting file is the client's, not the drafter's. When the client dies, the rights they held over it pass to their personal representatives, which is why an executor who asks for the file is usually asking for something they are already entitled to and a disappointed relative who asks is not.

This produces the situation that causes most of the friction. The people with the strongest reason to want the file, because they were left out or left less than they expected, are the people with the weakest claim to it. And the executor who can call for the file is quite often the sibling whose share the file might undermine.

Larke v Nugus, and what it actually asks for

England and Wales resolve that through a convention rather than a statute. The relevant authority is Larke v Nugus, a 1979 Court of Appeal decision reported much later at [2000] WTLR 1033, in which the court criticised a firm for standing on its privilege and forcing a claimant into proceedings to find out circumstances the firm could simply have described.

The practice that grew out of it, discussed in the Law Society's practice note on disputed wills, is that where there is a serious dispute about the validity of a will and the person who prepared it is a material witness to its preparation and execution, they should make a statement of what they know available rather than wait to be compelled. A request of that kind is usually called a Larke v Nugus request, and a reasonable one covers ground like how the instructions were taken, whether the testator was seen alone, who else was present or involved, what was said about earlier wills and about anyone excluded, and what the drafter observed about the testator's understanding.

Three things about it are worth being clear on. It is a convention, not a statutory right: the Law Society's own guidance tells a recipient that it is under no duty to comply, and in Dahlman v Oxley in 2025 a High Court judge described Larke v Nugus as ambiguous on whether a duty to respond arises at all, while noting that responding promptly is common practice and that everyone involved is expected to try to avoid costly litigation. It is not automatic: a request with no real question about validity behind it is far easier to refuse. And it is aimed at the circumstances rather than at the paperwork, so the answer is often a narrative statement, sometimes with copies from the file, and the drafter will usually want the executors' agreement first, because the privilege in the file passed to them on death.

Asking, in the order that tends to work

The sequence people generally follow is unremarkable and mostly about getting the cheap steps out of the way first.

  • Search the probate record to establish whether a grant has issued and, if it has, obtain the will itself
  • If no grant has issued, a standing search under the Non-Contentious Probate Rules 1987 will report one when it does
  • Where there is a real question about validity and time is short, a caveat under those same rules is the mechanism that stops a grant issuing while the question is looked at
  • Write to whoever prepared the will, saying plainly what the concern about validity is and what circumstances the request goes to
  • Ask the executors separately for what they hold, since they may be entitled to the file even where the requester is not

Being specific matters more than being forceful. A letter that names the concern, a date and a document tends to get an answer; a letter that asks for everything tends to get a refusal that is hard to argue with.

When the answer is no, and when it does not matter

A refusal is not the end of the road, but the roads out of it are all more expensive than asking. Disclosure can be sought once proceedings are on foot, the court has power under the Senior Courts Act 1981 to order a person to produce a testamentary document, and an unreasonable refusal can count against the refuser when the costs of a later claim are decided.

It is also worth saying that not every grievance about a will is a question about its validity, and the two get conflated constantly. A spouse, civil partner, child, cohabitant or someone the deceased was maintaining may have a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 whether the will is valid or not, ordinarily within six months of the grant. That claim asks whether the will made reasonable provision, not whether it was properly made, and it does not need the drafting file to get started.

The uncomfortable general truth is that a file is only as good as what somebody wrote down at the time, and plenty of files turn out to contain very little. That is the argument for keeping your own record while you are alive rather than hoping someone else kept one. You can make or update a will through our individual wills service, and the papers that sit behind it, instructions, earlier versions and the note of why a decision was made, stay in your document vault where your executors can find them. If you are working out whether there is a dispute here at all, our guide on common will mistakes covers the problems that most often turn into one, and what happens without a will covers the intestacy position if a will fails.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.