Why a Scottish guardian must say yes before the job is theirs
In Scotland a guardian named by a parent is not in post until they accept, and the appointment only needs writing and a signature. Here is how the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 handles who raises a child when both parents have died.


In Scotland, naming a guardian for your children does not make anyone a guardian. The person you name has to accept the role, and until they do the appointment has not taken effect. That small rule in the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 shapes a good deal of what follows, because it means a guardian is chosen twice: once by the parent who writes the name down, and again by the person who has to decide whether to take it on.
This article is about Scotland. England, Wales and Northern Ireland have their own rules and the position below is not theirs. What follows is general information rather than legal advice. The law changes, and anyone with a particular family situation should take it to a qualified professional.
Scottish law talks about responsibilities before rights
The 1995 Act does not start from the idea of custody. It starts from parental responsibilities, and section 1 lists them: to safeguard and promote the child's health, development and welfare, to provide direction and guidance appropriate to the child's stage of development, to keep up personal relations and direct contact where the child lives elsewhere, and to act as the child's legal representative. Those duties apply only so far as it is practicable and in the child's interests to comply with them.
Age matters to how long they last. The full set of responsibilities runs while the child is under 16. After that, what remains is the duty of guidance, and it continues until the young person is 18. A guardian appointed under the Act is not given some lesser, separate role. Section 7(5) says a guardian has, in respect of the child, the responsibilities and the rights that sections 1 and 2 give a parent, subject to any court order, and that those sections apply to a guardian as they apply to a parent.
So when this article says "guardian", it means someone who steps into the shoes of a parent in law, with the same legal responsibilities, until the child reaches the ages above.
Who holds the power to appoint
Section 7(1) lets a child's parent appoint a person to be guardian of the child in the event of the parent's death. There is a condition attached, and it is the one that catches families out. The appointment has no effect unless the parent, at the time of death, was entitled to act as the child's legal representative.
That condition is the link back to section 3, which says who has parental responsibilities and rights in the first place. A mother has them whatever her marital or civil partnership status. A father has them if he was married to the mother or in a civil partnership with her at the child's conception or afterwards, or if he is registered as the child's father under the relevant registration enactments. The section also covers some parents of children born through assisted reproduction under the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008.
The practical consequence is worth stating plainly. A father who is not married to the mother and is not registered on the birth record does not hold these rights by default, so an appointment he makes under section 7(1) would not meet the section's own condition. Whether someone holds them is a matter of the facts and the registers, not of what anyone assumes.
A guardian can also pick a successor. Section 7(2) allows a guardian to appoint someone to take their place if the guardian dies, again only by a signed written document.
What the appointment has to look like
The Act asks for two things: writing, and the parent's signature. Section 7(1)(a)(i) says the appointment is of no effect unless it is in writing and signed by the parent. It does not say the appointment has to sit inside a will. Many parents do put it in a will, because that is where the rest of their wishes for the children already live, but the section itself speaks of a signed writing.
Neither does section 7 prescribe witnesses for the appointment. Wills and other documents in Scotland are governed by their own formality rules, and a parent who puts the appointment inside a will brings that document's rules with it. The point here is narrower: the guardian provision in the 1995 Act does not add a further requirement of its own.
The guardian says yes, impliedly or in words
Section 7(3) provides that an appointment does not take effect until it is accepted, either expressly or impliedly by acts which are not consistent with any other intention. Acceptance can therefore be a plain statement that the person will do it. It can also be shown by conduct, such as taking the children in and acting as their carer, as long as the conduct does not point to a different explanation.
Nobody can be made to take the job by being named. A person who is asked, and who would rather not, is not bound by the appointment. That is the reason the question of who to name is more than a formality for the parent. A name written without a conversation is a name that may not be accepted.
Where a parent names more than one person, section 7(4) says any one or more of them can accept even if the others do not, unless the appointment expressly provides otherwise. If a parent names a couple and one of them declines, the other may accept office alone unless the document says something different.
When it takes effect, and the surviving parent
An appointment is about the parent's death, but it does not follow that the guardian takes the child on the day the first parent dies. Section 7(1)(b) says that any parental responsibilities or rights a surviving parent has continue alongside those of the appointee. In other words, the child's other parent keeps their own position, and the guardian's rights sit with theirs.
That is a feature of the Scottish scheme that may surprise someone expecting an appointment to displace the surviving parent. In practice the Act is built so that the appointment is a provision for the loss of parents, and it adds to rather than replaces the position of a parent who is still there.
Section 7(6) adds that deciding to appoint a guardian counts as a major decision involving the exercise of a parental right for the purposes of section 6.
Reading the guardian's role against a court order
Section 7(5) is subject to orders under section 11 or section 86. The rights and responsibilities of a guardian are those of a parent, and the court keeps its power to regulate them. A guardian is not outside the supervision of the courts any more than a parent would be.
If nobody has been named
Not every family has a guardian appointed. The Act does not say that a particular relative takes over in that case. Instead, section 11 is the route through which a person can ask a court to make an order about the child.
Section 11(1) lets the court make orders about parental responsibilities, parental rights, guardianship and the administration of the child's property. Section 11(2)(h) specifically lists an order appointing or removing a person as guardian. Sections 11(3) and 11(4) say who can apply: broadly, a person who does not have, and has never had, parental responsibilities or rights but claims an interest in the child, or a person who currently has them, with some further provision for people whose responsibilities or rights have been lost in particular ways. Section 11(5) says that "person" includes the child concerned, but it does not include a local authority.
The court procedure is set by the sheriff court rules, which change from time to time, so anyone needing to apply should check the current rules or ask a solicitor.
The test the court applies is in section 11(7)(a). The child's welfare is its paramount consideration, and it must not make an order unless it considers that it would be better for the child that the order be made than that none should be made at all. Section 11(7)(b) and (c) also require the court, taking account of the child's age and maturity and so far as practicable, to give the child an opportunity to say whether they want to express a view, to let them do so if they do, and to have regard to what they say. Section 11(10) presumes that a child of twelve or over is of sufficient age and maturity to form a view. A child does not have to be legally represented in these proceedings if they do not wish to be (section 11(9)).
Two consequences follow. First, a court deciding this is not bound to prefer any particular relative, and it looks at the child rather than at who has asked. Second, the process takes time and happens at a point when the family is already grieving, which is exactly the situation a signed appointment is there to ease.
Guardian and money are separate questions
The Act is about who looks after the child. Who manages money a child inherits is a separate matter, usually set out in the will itself, and the two roles do not have to be held by the same person.
For readers weighing what to put in writing for their children, our guide on what happens if you die without a will describes what the law does when nothing has been set down, and our guide on Scottish and English wills compared explains why a Scottish document follows different rules from one made in England. Families with young children can see how this fits into the wider picture on our young families page, and our individual wills service is the place to begin drafting a will that includes the appointment.
Looking at the choice again
A name on a page is a decision made on one day, and families change. Children grow, a named guardian moves away or has a change in health, a relationship ends, or the person you chose simply stops being the right fit. Reading the appointment again when something in the family changes, and checking that the person named still knows and still would accept, is a sensible habit, because the whole scheme depends on that acceptance at the moment it is needed.
Sources
- Children (Scotland) Act 1995, section 1 (opens in a new tab), legislation.gov.uk, parental responsibilities and the ages 16 and 18
- Children (Scotland) Act 1995, section 3 (opens in a new tab), legislation.gov.uk, who holds parental responsibilities and rights, including unmarried fathers
- Children (Scotland) Act 1995, section 7 (opens in a new tab), legislation.gov.uk, appointment of guardians, writing and signature, acceptance, successor guardians, surviving parent
- Children (Scotland) Act 1995, section 11 (opens in a new tab), legislation.gov.uk, court orders, appointment of a guardian by the court, who may apply, welfare test and the child's views
Written by
TheWILL.ai Team
The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.


