Estate Planning

The will becomes a public record; the lawyer's file does not

TheWILL.ai Team

American practice separates two things sharply. The will goes to the courthouse and becomes readable by anyone; the drafting file stays privileged, with one long-standing exception that exists for exactly this situation.

The will becomes a public record; the lawyer's file does not
This article coversUnited StatesUnited States

The will and the lawyer's file are two different objects in American practice, and they travel in opposite directions after a death. The will goes to the courthouse, often under a statutory duty with a deadline attached, and becomes a record any member of the public may read. The file stays where it is, privileged, and gets prised open only through a doctrine built for precisely the argument that is probably going on.

Probate in the United States is state law, so fifty statute books are involved. The provisions named here are California's and New York's, plus the Uniform Probate Code where a state has adopted it, as at October 2026. This is general information, not legal advice; a probate attorney licensed in the relevant state is the person to ask.

Lodging the will is a duty, not a courtesy

Many states place an affirmative obligation on whoever is holding a will to deliver it to the court after the death, whether or not they intend to start a probate. California is the clearest example: section 8200 of the Probate Code requires the custodian of a will, within thirty days of learning of the death, to deliver the original to the clerk of the superior court of the county where the estate may be administered and to mail a copy to the person named as executor. The Uniform Probate Code takes a softer line: under section 2-516 the custodian must deliver the will with reasonable promptness, on the request of an interested person, to someone able to secure its probate or, if nobody is known, to a court. States that adopted the Code have varied the trigger, the recipient and the deadline.

Two things follow. A person holding a will who quietly sits on it is often in breach of a statute rather than merely being unhelpful, and in California the custodian is liable for damages caused by the failure. And where a deadline applies it gives a rough sense of when to start looking: in California, a month after the death, for a will known to exist, the courthouse is a reasonable place to check.

Once deposited, it is open

A will lodged with the court becomes part of the court's record, and court records in probate are generally public. In most counties that means a member of the public may inspect the will without showing an interest in the estate, though access rules and online availability vary from court to court. Many courts provide an online case index, and a copy can usually be requested from the clerk for a fee.

This is a sharper rule than the equivalent in most of the common-law world, where the will becomes public only once a grant has actually issued. In the United States the filing is often what makes it public, and the filing comes first.

Notice to heirs and devisees is a separate track

Being entitled to notice and being entitled to inspect are different things, and they run in parallel. In formal probate, notice of the petition generally goes to the heirs and to the devisees named in the will; some states allow an informal or summary route with notice given only afterwards. Either way, the personal representative has continuing duties to inform and account to the people interested in the estate. Under the Uniform Probate Code the personal representative must give written information of the appointment to the heirs and devisees within thirty days.

Notice tells a person that something is happening and gives them the chance to object. It does not by itself hand over the drafting papers, which is usually what the person actually wants.

Privilege survives death, with one exception built for this

The attorney-client privilege does not end when the client dies. The Supreme Court said so in Swidler and Berlin v United States in 1998, and the practical effect is that the drafting lawyer cannot simply be asked to explain what the testator told them.

The long-standing exception is the testamentary one. Where the dispute is among the people claiming through the deceased, rather than between the estate and an outsider, the privilege gives way as to communications relevant to the intended disposition, on the reasoning that the client would have wanted their intentions carried out rather than concealed. The Restatement of the Law Governing Lawyers states the exception, and it is recognised in one form or another across the states. Separately, the personal representative succeeds to the client's position, so the representative can generally waive privilege where a beneficiary cannot.

New York's pre-objection examination is the closest thing to a right

New York goes further than most states and gives a potential objectant a procedural entitlement before they have to commit to litigation. Under section 1404 of the Surrogate's Court Procedure Act, a person who may object to a will's probate may examine the attesting witnesses and the lawyer who prepared it, and may do so before filing objections. The Uniform Rules for the Surrogate's Court, at 22 NYCRR 207.27, confine the examination, absent special circumstances, to the three years before the will's date and the two years after it or until the death, whichever is shorter, which is where arguments about the scope of a request usually land.

That combination, an examination as of right plus a bounded document window, does much the same work that a statement-of-circumstances convention does in England and Wales, and it does it through procedure rather than professional practice.

The practical sequence

  • Check whether the will has been lodged, since in some states, California among them, it must be within weeks of the death regardless of whether a probate is started
  • Read it from the court record, which in many places requires nothing more than asking the clerk
  • Watch for the petition and the notice to heirs and devisees, which names who is applying and on what basis
  • Establish which state's law governs before relying on anything written about another one, because the deadlines and the entitlements both change at the state line
  • Treat the drafting file as the hardest part, reachable through the testamentary exception and, in New York, through a pre-objection examination

A will made through our individual wills service can sit in your document vault together with the instructions and earlier versions behind it, so the record of why a choice was made does not live only in a firm's file. Whether a lawyer is needed at all is a question our guide on whether you need a lawyer to write a will takes up.

Sources

Written by

TheWILL.ai Team

The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.

We use cookies to improve your experience. See our Cookie policy (opens in a new tab) for details.