Fifty states, fifty answers to who raises your children
In the United States there is no federal rule on who raises a child whose parents have died. Each state decides, and the same nomination in a will can be handled quite differently in California, Texas and New York.


No federal law decides who raises an American child whose parents have both died. Guardianship of minors belongs to the states, so the answer depends on the state where the child lives, and even the basic mechanics differ from one state line to the next.
This article is about the United States, where guardianship is state law. The provisions named below are California's, Texas's and New York's, and the Uniform Probate Code, a model text that states may adopt in whole, in part or not at all. Rules change, and this is general information rather than legal advice; for an individual case, take it to a qualified professional.
A model code, not a national one
The Uniform Probate Code is drafted by the Uniform Law Commission and has no force until a state legislature enacts it. Its Article V deals with guardianship of minors. Where a state has adopted it, section 5-202 lets a parent appoint a guardian for a minor child by will or other signed writing, and the appointment can be revoked or amended before a court confirms it. Maine's Probate Code, which follows the model, shows the shape: the appointment takes effect when the parent dies, is adjudicated incapacitated, or is certified by a physician as no longer able to care for the child, whichever comes first, and a person who was nominated has priority when someone petitions the court to appoint a guardian, unless the appointment has been prevented or ended under the Code's termination provisions, and the nominee must accept within 30 days.
Other states built their own rules long before or without the model, which is why the three examples below differ.
California separates the child from the child's property
California's Probate Code lets a parent nominate a guardian of a child's person, estate, or both (section 1500), subject to conditions: broadly, the other parent agrees, or has died or cannot consent. The nomination can be made in a signed writing as well as in the petition or at the hearing (section 1502), and unless the writing says otherwise it stays effective after the nominator dies. Property is a separate track. Under section 1501, a parent or anyone else who leaves property to a child can nominate someone to manage that property only.
The court still has the last word. For the estate, section 1514 directs the court to appoint the nominee unless it finds the nominee unsuitable. For the person of the child, the court applies the custody standards of the Family Code, so the nomination is something it takes into account rather than something it must obey.
Texas gives the nominee a statutory preference
Texas treats the surviving parent as the natural guardian of the child's person and the person entitled to be appointed guardian of the estate (Estates Code section 1104.051). The surviving parent may also, by will or written declaration, appoint any eligible person as guardian of the child's person, effective after the parent's death or incapacity (section 1104.053).
After the surviving parent dies, the court is told to appoint the person named in preference to anyone else who would otherwise be entitled, unless it finds the nominee disqualified, deceased, unwilling to serve, or not in the children's best interests. Refusal is built into the statute: a person named can decline, and the court then looks elsewhere.
New York needs a probate step before the guardian can act
New York's Domestic Relations Law section 81 allows a surviving parent to dispose of the custody of a child under eighteen by deed or last will, and to appoint different people as guardian of the person and guardian of the property. A parent may also, in a will, name the other parent as guardian. The appointment is effective if, when the will is admitted to probate, the other parent has died or is adjudicated incompetent.
The distinctive point is timing. Under Surrogate's Court Procedure Act section 1710, no one may exercise power as guardian by virtue of a parent's will unless the will has been admitted to probate and recorded and letters of guardianship have been issued. A name in the will is the start of a court process, not the end of one.
Who decides when nobody was named
Without a valid nomination, a court chooses. Someone interested in the child's welfare petitions, and the judge decides who should be appointed on the child's best interests. In California the court may consider the preference of a child old enough to express a reasoned one (section 1514), and in New York the Surrogate's Court is the court that issues letters of guardianship. Which court hears the case, and which relatives have priority, if any, depends on the state.
What the rules have in common
- A parent's nomination is made in writing, usually a will, though several states accept another signed document.
- A child's person and a child's property can be handled separately, and in some states by different people.
- The nominee does not take over automatically: a court appoints, confirms or issues letters.
- A named person is generally free to decline.
If you are making or updating a will, our individual wills service covers naming guardians, and our page for young families explains how it fits with the rest of the plan. Our guide on what happens without a will describes the default rules that fill the gap.
A nomination in a will is best understood as a parent's statement of preference. A court weighs it, often heavily, but it remains answerable to the child's best interests and to the state's own procedure.
Sources
- California Probate Code, sections 1500, 1501, 1502 and 1514 (opens in a new tab), California Legislative Information, nomination of a guardian of the person or estate, form and effect of the nomination, and court appointment
- Texas Estates Code, sections 1104.051 and 1104.053 (opens in a new tab), Texas Legislature, natural guardians and appointment of a guardian of the person by will or written declaration
- New York Domestic Relations Law, section 81 (opens in a new tab), New York State Senate, testamentary appointment of a guardian of the person and of the property
- New York Surrogate's Court Procedure Act, section 1710 (opens in a new tab), New York State Senate, probate and letters required before a testamentary guardian acts
- Maine Revised Statutes, Title 18-C, sections 5-202 and 5-204 (opens in a new tab), Maine Legislature, a state enactment of the Uniform Probate Code's parental appointment and priority provisions
Written by
TheWILL.ai Team
The editorial team at TheWILL.ai, dedicated to making estate planning accessible and modern.


